Geoffrey is killed during the a biking crash in the 1186 and you can Constance partnered (2) Ranulph de Blundeville, cuatro th Earl out of Chester, towards step 3 rd March 1188, during the a married relationship developed of the Queen Henry 11. This relationship deteriorated and you can Ranulph imprisoned Constance during the 1196. Rebellions was stimulated all over Brittany on her behalf and you can Ranulph put out their during the 1198. Back to Brittany, Constance had their own relationship annulled and later within the 1198, she got People de- Tours just like the her ‘second’ husband.
Constance passed away old 40, (perhaps out of leprosy, maybe following childbirth in order to twin girls) towards the 5 th September 1201 on Nantes
The theory one to Constance had an affair with John pursuing the death of Geoffrey and you can just before John’s matrimony in order to Isabella from Gloucester from inside the 1189, and that she try mother so you can Joanna is really controversial and enjoys provoked far talk within this genealogical sectors.
By just that have sex with John, aside from affect him a baby, Constance could have established an initial-education matchmaking of affinity along with John’s sisters –– plus John’s sibling Geoffrey
One feedback out of a good genealogist claims you to ‘the latest journal ‘The brand new Plantagenet Connection’ possess composed an ahnentafel regarding E Plantagenet, partner regarding Henry V11, gives Joanna’s mother’s identity once the Constance (perhaps misnamed Clemence?), Duchess away from Brittany. This is the Constance who was John’s cousin-in-laws! Considering the well-recognized animosity between John and you can Constance and her own tries to force her son Arthur’s interests so far as the fresh new throne out of England is actually worried (so we all recognize how disastrously you to proved!), I must say i select the recommended relationships a small hard to consume. The Constance that background portrays will not hit myself given that towards whom John could easily coerce into the sleep.’
‘ A principle who would choose Joanna’s mommy while the Constance doesn’t account fully for a highly crucial reason for canon laws. Who does signify some shade of number need certainly to seriously have come down seriously to all of us, whether or not it involved brand new ask for it, the latest deliberations, or perhaps the real dispensation by itself. As much as i was aware, absolutely nothing of the kind can be acquired.’
personal viewpoint for what it’s worth, is that got Constance been mom out-of Joanna she would absolutely keeps introduced their own upwards inside her home along with her term might possibly be too known as Constance’s other students by Geoffrey (Eleanor, Reasonable Housemaid out-of Brittany, Matilda/Maud regarding Brittany and you will Arthur).
Agatha was born regarding 1168 when you look at the Chartley Palace, Staffordshire. It’s well known that she try a mistress off John and some family trees render their, even though single, as the mom from Joanna. Most genealogists however are of the opinion that it is only conjecture one the woman is Joanna’s mother once the no evidence otherwise ideas can be found to show this.
Although this was not good consanguineous relationships but among attraction, one basic-education relationship will have rendered matrimony between Constance and any one of John’s brothers hopeless instead a dispensation –– and therefore given the party’s score would have had to are from the newest pope himself
One supply frequently given is Sir William Dugdale, from the Baronage regarding England (1675-6). He states their source as Dr David Howell’s ‘History of Wales’ (1584). Powell’s job is an increased edition of H Lloyd’s translation out-of ‘The latest Historie out-of Cambria’ because of the 12 th century Saint Caradoc away from Llancarfan. An alternate origin, ‘Magna Carta Barons’ because of the Charles Browning, copyright 1969 plus brands Agatha de Ferrers, child from Robert de- Ferrers, next Earl of derby, while the Joanna’s mom.
In the event she can’t be totally overlooked since a candidate for mom away from Joanna, absolutely there would be particular shade out-of their into the an excellent chronicle or any other historical site, in the event the she got in fact become mom of your own wife away from the Prince regarding Northern Wales.